The Perfect Popper

The Perfect Popper - Hot and tasty - A kitchen workhorse and the foundation of many party Appetizers, Hors d'oeuvre, and Snacks
Rated 4.7 / 5 based on 11 reviews

Prep Time: 10 min
Total Time: 35 min
Yield: 8 Serving

Nutrition Facts:
240 calories
9 grams fat



There are essentially 5 functional parts of the perfect popper:

1.The pepper
2.The filling
3.The initial batter
4.The breading
5.The final batter

This recipe is for 150-200 poppers (to be made in advance, silly).

The peppers: Fresh jalapenos.

A potato peeler with a pointed end is the perfect tool for deseeding. The radius of the peeler allows you to make a hole about 1 cm in diameter, which is optimized for efficient seed removal, effective stuffing of popper, and minimal leakage (more on that later). Stab the pepper adjacent to the stem, with the stem on the concave side of your peeler, remove, turn pepper roughly 1 radian and repeat. After 3 or 4 stabs, you will have separated the stem from the rest of the pepper. Pull out, with slight twisting motion, and you will remove most of the seeds. A little additional scraping may be required to get out the innards. Put aside and repeat until done.

The filling:

Mix equal weights of cream cheese, finely shredded cheddar (sharp or, and finely shredded Monterey jack. My batch used 8 ounces of each. Mix these together in a bowl, until additional mixing makes no change in consistency.

The batters:

Both of them have basically the same ingredients. The differences are in consistency (and time of preparation). Don't use milk for the batter. It won't grab the pepper, because of the waxy consistency. Beer works best of beer, water, & milk. Use generic fried vegetable batter (I used the Chuck Wagon stuff), and an equal part of flour. Season with garlic salt, black pepper, onion salt, and powdered cayenne for color (both in the batter and in the unsuspecting faces of your guests). I used about 1 teaspoon of each to about 1/2 cup each of chuck wagon stuff and flour.

For the initial batter, you want it very thick, thicker than pancake batter. This is to hold the breading to the popper. If you add too much beer at the start, add flour to thicken. I think it took about half a beer for this.

For the final batter, you want it very thin, it should take less than a second for the batter to 'climb' the tines of a fork when removed and held vertically over the batter. This has an added bonus of making those little crunchy things to eat with the poppers. This was still less than a whole beer, so don't get too carried away- make it thick ad add the beer in small amts. Remember, don't make this until you're serving them!

The breading:
Just a plate with a pile of white cornmeal, dry.

The process:

After coring a sink full of peppers, stuff them all full of the cheese. Use your pinkie to pack the cheese in good, leaving about a 1/4 inch divot on the end of the pepper (recessed cheese, in case I'm not being clear). Then line up your thick batter and corn meal, and an oven tray lined with aluminum foil. Dip the pepper in the batter, holding by the cheese and tip ends. Allow as much of the excess batter as you can stand to drip off. Then place the pepper in the corn meal. Pick up a handful of meal and bury the pepper. Place your hand on top of the pile (cupped), and apply some light pressure to help everything pack together. Pick up the pepper and shake off the excess meal. Again, handle the pepper by the tips, it helps minimize the bald spots. Place the pepper on the tray, and repeat a million (OK, 200, but it seems like a million) times. Place the pan in the freezer. This is called flash freezing. After about half an hour (the time it takes to fill the next tray) remove the first tray, and place all of the poppers in a big ziplock bag. Put the bag back in the freezer. Wait overnight or longer.

The serving of and eating of poppers:

Heat up grease in your fry daddy. Make the final (thin) batter. Get some of your frozen poppers. Some of the breading may have come off in spots, don't sweat it. Dip the popper in the thin batter and put in the grease. Cook until golden brown. Conveniently, this is also the point where the cheese is melted, yet the pepper isn't overcooked. Pop in yer mouth.

Possible variations:

A friend suggested that the initial batter/breading might have nothing to do with the success of the final batter sticking, that the freezing may be the trick there. If true, It would save a lot of work! I haven't had a chance to try it yet. Please tell me how these turn out when you try them!


Latest Reviews

"I made this for New Year's Eve. Followed the recipe exactly & it came out just like the photo-but I was a bit disappointed with it. Some guests enjoyed it, some I think didn't as they didn't go back for seconds. Husband commented yuck. I wasn't a big fan either, would rate it as just okay, not worth the effort. I'll be going back to the normal cob loaf dips, much prefer those. Won't make this again." - sherri3802

"is there a truck to adding the cream cheese where it doesn't circle? I've the recipe and it tastes great but the crea. cheese juat doesn't fully break down." - seamus m.

"Seven layer taco dip made with refried beans, sour cream, and salsa is the perfect platter for..." - suzanne m. munson

"i see alot of people substituting alot of ingredients in this recipe, which kinda defeats the purpose. ive been using it for years, this is a genuine sauce recipe from someone who knew better than us. for instance, the fennel is a key ingredient so dont skip it. once i didnt have any so i added ... " - danboy357

"Stop right here, and NEVER make another spaghetti sauce recipe. I love to cook and have tried a lot of them-this is by far the best! I tried the recipe 3 ways because I had a lot of garden tomatoes to use and it's the end of the 2018 growing season. See below for tips you might want to use on this ... " - krissers

"I love this. Has anyone tried canning this?" - hillzo

Happy cooking...